Quality appraisal in systematic reviews of public health interventions: an empirical study on the impact of choice of tool on meta-analysis

Episode von Medizin - Open Access LMU - Teil 20/22 von Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München · 31. Juli 2012

Introduction Systematic reviews are a cornerstone of evidence-based public health. The method of appraising the quality of different intervention and observational study designs in such reviews remains an important challenge. This article examines the applicability of selected quality appraisal tools (QATs) and the impact of choice of tool on the meta-analysis of a published systematic review. Methods The authors selected a systematic review on the effectiveness of hand washing with soap in preventing diarrhoea, covering a range of epidemiological study designs. 6 QATs were used to assess 13 studies meeting their inclusion criteria; component sections/questions were coded numerically to derive a summary score between -1 (low quality) and +1 (high quality) for each QAT and study. Heterogeneity in study quality was evaluated graphically using traffic light schemes and spider charts. Random effects meta-analysis was undertaken for all studies; sensitivity analyses for each QAT included only those studies with a score of 0 or above. Results The authors found substantial heterogeneity in summary scores for a given study. Their main meta-analysis yielded an OR of 0.60 (95% CI 0.47 to 0.77) with most sensitivity analyses giving similar pooled effect sizes with wider CIs. Discussion The six QATs differ greatly in applicability across study designs, approach to quality appraisal (ie, scale vs checklist, presence/absence of summary score), coverage of domains and quality of component questions and answers. Learning from advantages and disadvantages of each QAT, we recommend research into the development of a reliable QAT with a broad applicability across study designs.

Weitere Episoden von „Medizin - Open Access LMU - Teil 20/22“

• Movement kinematic after deep brain stimulation associated microlesions 1. Oktober 2012
• Disease Progression Mediated by Egr-1 Associated Signaling in Response to Oxidative Stress 1. Oktober 2012
• Multiple pathways of plasmid DNA transfer in Helicobacter pylori 20. September 2012
• Closing the case of APOE in multiple sclerosis: no association with disease risk in over 29 000 subjects 1. September 2012
• Real-time transcriptional profiling of cellular and viral gene expression during lytic cytomegalovirus infection. 1. September 2012
• Short-term effects of air temperature on blood markers of coagulation and inflammation in potentially susceptible individuals 1. September 2012
• Medical futility at the end of life: the perspectives of intensive care and palliative care clinicians. 1. September 2012
• A comparison of different linkage statistics in small to moderate sized pedigrees with complex diseases 6. August 2012
• Pantothenate kinase-associated neurodegeneration 1. August 2012
• Quantitative Expression of C-Type Lectin Receptors in Humans and Mice 1. August 2012
• Decidual Macrophages Are Significantly Increased in Spontaneous Miscarriages and Over-Express FasL 23. Juli 2012
• Thure von Uexkülls semiotisches Modell des Menschen als Grundlage für eine moderne Theorie der Homöopathie 12. Juli 2012
• Germline mutations in the DNA damage response genes BRCA1, BRCA2, BARD1 and TP53 in patients with therapy related myeloid neoplasms 1. Juli 2012
• A Genome-Wide Association Meta-Analysis of Circulating Sex Hormone-Binding Globulin Reveals Multiple Loci Implicated in Sex Steroid Hormone Regulation 1. Juli 2012
• Patients' preferences in treatment for neovascular age-related macular degeneration in clinical routine 1/2 1. Juli 2012

Alle Episoden von Medizin - Open Access LMU - Teil 20/22 · Mehr Bildung-Podcasts