Stefanie Haustein: Challenges of closed vs opportunities of open: A data feminist reflection on the bibliometrics community’s shift to open infrastructure
Episode von RMZ Science Works von Robert K. Merton Zentrum für Wissenschaftsforschung · 26. März 2025 · 49 min
For decades, research assessment infrastructure has been shaped by closed, centralized systems that prioritize selectivity, reinforce hierarchies, and define what counts as scholarly impact. This talk traces the historical evolution of bibliometrics, from the first citation analysis in the early 20th century via the revolutionary development of the Science Citation Index to the dominance of commercial data analytics companies like Clarivate and Elsevier today. The talk will highlight how these infrastructures have perpetuated power imbalances—determining who gets to define impact, what types of knowledge are valued, and whose labor is made visible.
Currently research assessment and the underlying bibliometric infrastructure are undergoing a transformation. The increasing availability of open bibliographic sources (e.g., Crossref, OpenAlex, DataCite, DOAJ), metadata accessibility, and alternative models of research evaluation are challenging traditional hierarchies and enabling more inclusive and transparent assessment practices.
Using a data feminist lens, this talk will critically examine both the past and present of research assessment infrastructure, advocating for a shift that embraces pluralism, contextualizes metrics, and recognizes the diverse contributions that shape scholarly knowledge. By reflecting on historical lessons and current developments, we can envision a research assessment system that is more equitable, open, and reflective of the complexities of academic work.
Weitere Episoden von „RMZ Science Works“
- Cornelia Schendzielorz /Justo Serrano-Zamora /Staffan Edling: Science under pressure: Engaging with science and democracy in hybrid sites 22. Juli 2026
- Claudia Göbel: A fresh look at science-public relations, their problems, and digital transformations 24. Juni 2026
- Susanne Wollin-Giering & Markus Hoffmann: Epistemic factors affecting the (dis)continuation of research with missing resources 10. Juni 2026
- Yoanna Yankova/Jens Ambrasat: Promotion into the worse? Gendered culture in academia 27. Mai 2026
- Ayat Mirzaie/Masoumeh Qarakhani: Scientific professionalism under constraint: Associations, expertise boundaries, and external pressure 13. Mai 2026
- Dieter Plehwe: Science and think tanks: A complicated relationship 29. April 2026
- Catherine Herfeld: Model Transfer and its Role in Awakening Sleeping Beauties in Science 15. April 2026
- Veit Braun: Memories Are Made of This: Materielle Erinnerung in Biobanken 4. März 2026
- Paula Muhr: Limits to the Circulation of Epistemic Critique in the Recent Reanalyses of the EHT Images of the M87* Black Hole 18. Februar 2026
- Willem Halffman/Serge Horbach: The library and the database: two imaginaries for the research literature 4. Februar 2026
- Sebastian Büttner: In der Wissenskrise? Politisierung von Wissen und Expertise als Herausforderung für die Soziologie 21. Januar 2026
- Sheena F. Bartscherer/Sven Ulpts/Bart Penders/Sarahanne Field: The (anti)social replication of replication: exploring how replication moves across epistemic communities 7. Januar 2026
- Marco Seeber: The evolution of the scientific publishing market, its drivers and implications 10. Dezember 2025
- Chérifa Boukacem-Zeghmouri & Jie Xu: The big transformation? Early Career Researchers as they race in the open scholarly world. Perspectives from France and China 26. November 2025
- Jesper W. Schneider: Questionable Research Practices, what are they and so should we worry? 12. November 2025
Alle Episoden von RMZ Science Works · Mehr Wissenschaft-Podcasts